Thursday, September 17, 2015

Ltaken seminar and Iran and Washington Saturday March 7th at SBE


This past weekend I was in Washington DC with our youth on a wonderful social justice weekend.  While we have been doing youth group trips to various cities over the years, this trip was unique.  First we joined a program called L’taken, which means “to fix”, sponsored by the Religious Action Centre. For more than 50 years, "the RAC" has been the hub of Jewish social justice and legislative activity in Washington, they educate and mobilize the Reform Jewish community on legislative and social concerns, advocating on more than 70 different issues, including economic justice, civil rights, religious liberty, Israel and more.  The L’taken program brings  around 300 teenagers from around north American to take an in depth look at social concerns and then learn how to take action on those issues.  For example, we talked about homelessness and poverty and heard from a former homeless man named Steve who was abused and lived on a bench for two years about a block from the white house. He is now able to find work and a home but talked about his struggles.  We then learned about the root causes of poverty – mental illness, homelessness, abuse, drug and alcohol etc. then we talked about how to take action on poverty. We studied Jewish texts on the mitzvoth that require us to help the needy.  We talked about how we can do food drives and volunteers at soup kitchens.  But these address the symptoms, not solve the problem.  The government can have a much bigger role in legislating towards alleviating poverty such as raising the minimum wage or better health care or federal job training.  As Canadians we were lucky to learn about how Canada has taken a much more progressive role in these issues, but while we have accomplished a lot the work is far from done.  So we learned how to lobby the government to make effective change through new and better laws. 
After poverty we focused on Israel, women’s’ rights, climate change, worldwide malaria and more.  Each time doing the same thing, examining the issues, learning the root causes, studying Jewish values that correspond and finding out ways to take action to solve the problems.  Of course we had time to hang out with other teenagers, have great meals, see the sights of Washington like the monuments, museums and shopping and stay up late eating pizza.  But we also learned a lot and the culmination was our visit Monday morning to the Canadian Embassy.  Throughout Sunday, we focused on how to write a speech and present it to legislators and other government representatives.  Monday was the time to put our work into action. Each student put on his or her best professional attire, wrote a speech about an issue they felt strongly about and entered the embassy board room to meet with our Canadian ambassadors’ representatives.  We spoke mainly on three issues – a strong relationship between Canada and Israel, Canada’s role in addressing climate change and women’s’ rights.  For two of these issues, we were preaching to the choir.  Canada has led the way on fighting for women’s rights on a global scale.  Canada has also been a great friend to Israel with economic and military trade and support.  On climate change we felt Canada could do more by donating more to the worldwide green fund, curbing greenhouse gases and switching to renewable energy.  I sat back with amazement as our teenagers delivered their words with great emotion and seriousness, forcing the embassy officials to take notes and answer how our government can do better.  It was a great weekend and hopefully we can continue to build on the work by meeting with our MP and MPP’s here in Oakville. 
In the discussion on Israel it was hard not to notice events happening around us in Washington.  Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu had arrived to speak at the AIPAC conference on Sunday and Monday and then was going to address the US house of representatives on Tuesday, one of just a handful of foreign leaders to ever have that opportunity.  It was all over the news and seemingly all everyone could talk about. 
The topic of Netanyahu’s speech as we all know was about the current round of negotiations between The P5+1, a group of six world powers[1] which in 2006 joined the diplomatic efforts with Iran with regard to its nuclear program. P5 are the five permanent members of the UN Security Council, namely United States, Russia, China, United Kingdom, and France, plus Germany
Israel is clearly not on that list and I am amazed that our little tiny country has such a voice in world affairs.  This issue is of particular importance because while no country in the world seems to be happy that Iran is trying to acquire nuclear weapons, there is only one country that is a target, and this is Israel.  And not just hints, Iranian supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has called for the annihilation of IsraelThe former PM of Iran Amhanejiad denies the Holocaust and calls for Israel’s destruction time and time again.  Not of the p plus 1 countries have been called out for obliteration like Israel, which also happens to be within firing distance of Iran’s new rockets.  Those rockets were just tested over the past few months and can hit our entire homeland with ease.  What if they carried nuclear war heads?  We are not at war with Iran but it is clear that Iran sponsor terrorism by Hezbollah and Hamas to attack Israel.  They are involved in supplying money and arms to the regimes in Syria and Lebanon and support all anti-Israel activity.  They walk the walk and talk the talk.  So why would Israel want a country that calls for its destruction to be in possession of nuclear weapons, of course we are doing everything we can to halt their progress.  The UN in 2006 upon heard of Iran’s plans to develop the bomb imposed a halt, to no avail.  For years they passed sanctions and demanded inspections, some worked for a little while, some were merely window dressing but Iran continued.  They build bunkers underground, they have over 10,000 centrifuges, and they brought in experts from Russia.  They are going full speed ahead.  Israel tried other options such as computer viruses which set back their work for a few years but nothing has worked.  It is possible there is a bombing option but it presents many problems.  The sites are spread out, hard to find and extremely difficult to neutralize effectively.  Iran would bomb Israel in retaliation, perhaps other Arab countries would join, and that could be disaster. 

Back to Netanyahu, he was called by the Congress speaker of the house Rp. John Boehner to come speak.  Here is the political side.  While it does seem appropriate for a representative from Israel to provide information to congress on how they view the negotiations with Iran, there are so many problems here.  One is that Boehner did not consult the white house on this invitation, and skipped protocol.  The white house does not want Netanyahu to speak in the middle of these negotiations.  Moreover the house is controlled by republicans and the white house by democrats, it’s making Israel into a partisan issue.  The greatest fear would be that Israel’s best ally America, will be driven by politics on supporting Israel.  So it becomes a wedge issue.  AIPAC gives equal support to both major parties in America, because no matter who is in power in which office, the best case scenario would be to support Israel, economically and militarily and diplomatically.  But this might drive a wedge into that relationship. 

The other part is that Netanyahu himself is in election mode as Israeli’s go to the polls in two weeks to elect a prime minister.  Is it just a coincidence that he goes to Washington now?  Of course its politics, he wants to show how great a leader he is that he can go to Washington and speak in front of the entire nation on Israel’s behalf to stop Iran from going nuclear. 

Everyone believes that Iran should not have the bomb the real question is how to go about stopping them.  Forget all the politics, Bibi is right that they must be stopped, that is his strong advice, no more negotiations and freezes and maybes and pleases.  Full sanctions, no negotiations no bomb.

The other side, preferred by the UN, the p-5 and the white house, would be to negotiate because what other options are there. 

 

So here we are in Washington, visiting the embassy and then walking by the congressional buildings where the Israeli PM is about to speak. Our small group from Oakville witnessing history.  And then our teens spoke up about how much we support the strong connections between Canada and Israel, despite the lunacy that is Washington. 

While I do not claim to have any answers, as always it is vital to keep engaged in what is going on, to show our support for Israel, and to teach our young people about the issues of the day and how they can make a difference.  Because god needs us to take an active role in making the world a better place for us all.

Ken yehi ratzon.



No comments:

Post a Comment